5 Comments
User's avatar
NORMAN D Sanders Jr's avatar

Well, thank you for two things:

1. Validating my own inability to offer an opinion on what pictorial photography is or is not. I think, like Iris DeMent, I'll just "Let the Mystery Be".

2. I was horrified to read that the Fan Ho photo with the diagonal shadow, done in 1954, was a darkroom creation. All of us who have ever worked in darkrooms know that what emerges on a print is rarely just a straightforward transfer from neg to print. But this photograph presages by 75 years, almost, my current concern about not being able to differentiate between an image produced by AI from a prompt and an actual image. I guess my conclusion on this, now echoing Cormac McCarthy, is that the world has become "No Country for Old Men". :-D

Welcome back. Say hi to Madame Gough.

Gavin Gough's avatar

It might soon be time to retreat to a shack in the woods.

Madame Gough says hi too.

Jeremy Butler's avatar

Oh, how I wish I were going to be in London before 21 Feb 2027 and could see this exhibition in person! Alas, it is not to be.

And so I was pleased to be able to read your account of pictorialism in terms of your personal encounters with it and to see some of the astonishing photographs included in "Light and Magic".

The Tate offers its own definition of this elusive term, as you likely read: "Beginning in the 1880s, pictorialist photographers worked to create images that were as imaginative, expressive and technically considered as any painting or drawing."

As someone trained in the history and theory of the cinema, the timing of the pictorial photography movement (?) intrigues me, because it overlaps with the often-discussed “Lumière/ Méliès Dichotomy” of the late-19th and early 20th centuries. In sum, that dichotomy encapsulates the tension within early filmmaking between documenting reality (e.g., the Lumière brothers films of the 1890s) and fabricating reality (e.g., Georges Méliès's TRIP TO THE MOON, 1902).

Are these dichotomies unique to the 19th century? Probably not, but the possibility of the "mechanical reproduction" of reality certainly brought them into sharp focus, shall we say. (Apologies to Walter Benjamin.)

Gavin Gough's avatar

Thanks, Jeremy. That's an interesting point, I hadn't thought about similarities with cinema. Also, I'm envious of your training in the history and theory of cinema. However that came about, it was time well spent.

Jeremy Butler's avatar

I like to think it was time well spent! :)

At the very least, it earned me a position at the University of Alabama, where I taught film/TV studies for 40 years.